Buying a used KeyForge deck: checking all 36 cards
On this page
For a normal Archon KeyForge deck, verify all 36 cards against its identity list and unique card backs before buying it used. A loose replacement with the same title from another deck is not equivalent to the missing original. Agree separately on the physical deck, its condition and any official account-registration transfer. A deck name, ranking estimate or registration screenshot alone does not prove physical completeness.
Buy the fixed deck as a single object
KeyForge's standard Archon format uses the unique deck's fixed composition. You are not buying a pile of interchangeable singles to rebuild like a conventional constructed deck. Alliance and special formats have their own rules; a listing sold as an intact ordinary Archon deck should be checked against its own full identity.
The publisher's deck-clone announcement explicitly identifies missing or unusably damaged cards as a problem for a fixed deck. Its official replacement or clone offerings are separate services with their own availability and requirements. Do not assume that a seller can solve a missing card by adding a matching title from a different deck.
For a hypothetical sale, 35 correct cards plus one identically named card with another deck's back should be described as an incomplete or mixed deck, not an intact original. The exact practical remedy depends on current official services. Establish that remedy and its cost before buying, rather than treating it as guaranteed afterward.
Compare the physical cards with the identity list
Ask for a clear photograph of the identity/deck-list card and the backs of the physical cards. Read the unique deck name and identifying design. Then group the 36 cards in a way that lets you match every listed entry, including repeated titles where the list contains them.
Count occurrences, not just distinct names. If the identity list contains three copies of a title, showing one example does not prove all three are present. Conversely, a duplicate title in the deck is not necessarily a seller's mistake; the fixed list may require it.
| Check | Useful evidence | Problem it catches |
|---|---|---|
| Identity/deck-list card | Complete readable list | Wrong advertised deck |
| Total physical main cards | Count of 36 | Missing or extra cards |
| Every listed occurrence | Cards arranged to match the list | One duplicate masking another missing card |
| Unique card backs | Clear matching deck identity | Replacement from another deck |
| Extra reference/components | Separately itemised | Accessories being counted as main cards |
For online purchases, ask for enough photographs to inspect these checks without requiring the seller to share account credentials or private personal information. An itemised count is evidence of a claim; clear physical images make the claim reviewable.
Distinguish reference cards from the 36-card deck
Some KeyForge products and deck mechanics use reference cards or additional components. An identity card and applicable token-creature reference are not an excuse to count fewer than the normal 36 main cards. Describe extras separately so both parties understand what is included.
Suppose a listing says “38 cards” and contains 36 main cards, an identity card and a reference card. That can be a sensible package description if all items are identified. Another “38-card” listing might contain 35 correct main cards plus several loose extras. The package total is therefore not the completeness check.
Use columns for main cards, identity card and required references. If a special version or format changes the expected composition, inspect its official documentation instead of applying the ordinary Archon count blindly. This guide's 36-card check is deliberately scoped to the normal fixed deck.
Condition affects usability as well as appearance
Inspect creases, tears, delamination, bent corners and marks that may distinguish a card within its deck. Sleeves can conceal some visual differences during play but cannot turn a severely damaged physical card into an undamaged one. Event policies and a judge determine the acceptability of a questionable deck.
For a valuable purchase, inspect the worst-looking card as carefully as the attractive rare. A single unusable card can create a fixed-deck problem even if the rest are excellent. A listing's average condition hides that risk; ask whether any particular card has damage beyond the general description.
If a seller says an official clone solves the problem, request the current service details and identify what is actually being offered. A clone or translated deck can have distinct official identity handling. Do not mistake a homemade photocopy for an official replacement merely because it reproduces the text.
Physical possession and account registration are separate
The publisher's Master Vault ownership and dispute guidance describes official ways to handle deck-registration ownership. Receiving physical cards does not by itself show that your desired official account status has already transferred. Ask whether the deck is registered and how the parties will complete the current official process.
Keep any agreement about that process in the sale or trade description. A practical statement is: “The complete physical deck is included; the seller will perform the available official transfer to the buyer's account.” If no transfer is included or possible through the current process, disclose that before the buyer commits.
Do not request the seller's password or take over an entire account as a shortcut. Use the official deck-transfer or ownership-claim procedure with the evidence it currently requests. Disputes can require review; a receipt or photograph is useful evidence, but this guide does not promise an automatic decision or a fixed review deadline.
A rating is not a guaranteed performance result
A numerical community assessment can help organise browsing, but it is not a substitute for examining the fixed list and condition. It does not guarantee a tournament result, current legality or the seller's ownership of the physical deck. Do not describe an unverified ranking as a publisher-issued grade.
Before choosing a used deck, identify your goal: casual play, learning a particular house combination, collecting a name or attending a specified format. The most suitable evidence differs. A collector interested in artwork still needs completeness; a player additionally needs the current format requirements and an acceptable physical state.
Compare complete purchases rather than only sticker prices. An apparently cheap missing-card deck may require a service that is unavailable or costs more than the difference. An original hypothetical calculation can include quoted deck price, verified shipping and an actually available official remedy; leave the remedy unknown if it has not been confirmed.
Frequently asked questions
Can I replace a missing card with the same title from another deck?
Not as an ordinary intact Archon-deck replacement. Its unique identity and fixed composition matter. Check current official replacement or clone options instead of assuming loose singles are interchangeable.
Does the identity card count among the 36?
No. Keep the normal main-deck count separate from the identity card and any relevant reference components.
Does receiving the physical deck automatically transfer its online registration?
No. Agree and verify the available official account-transfer or ownership process separately from physical delivery.