What to do if a Cardmarket card arrives in worse condition
On this page
If a Cardmarket purchase arrives in worse condition than advertised, document the difference before confirming everything is correct. Compare the copy with Cardmarket’s official condition guide, take photographs and message the seller from the order page to seek a solution.
Check the card and listing
Keep a reference to the listing: set, language, foil status and advertised grade. Photograph front, back, edges and the problem under light that shows it honestly. If shipping damage is possible, keep the packaging too. Separate two questions: is it the right card, and does its condition match? A wrong language or printing should be described as a different issue.
Contact the seller first
Cardmarket recommends contacting the seller when the grade is wrong. Describe observable facts rather than only saying “this is not NM”: for example, “the back corner has a visible crease and the listing said Near Mint.” Attach images and suggest a concrete route, such as return or a partial adjustment if both sides find it appropriate. The platform gives a guideline for grade differences, but it does not replace agreement or fit every case equally.
If you cannot agree
Contact Cardmarket support from the order page. For protected shipments, check how to mark an issue before clicking a confirmation that may end protection. Keep communication on the platform and retain the packaging until the case is closed. Solutions and rights can differ by seller and shipment type; read Cardmarket’s current instructions for your order.
What to check before claiming
Open the order and save the offer details as agreed: card name, expansion, language, finish, quantity and announced condition. Then compare each received copy with these details. Sometimes the problem that seems to be about condition is another: a different edition, incorrect language or wrong foil print. Describe each difference separately so the seller can identify it. If a card arrives folded, it is not enough to say "it does not seem Near Mint"; indicate the fold, its position and how it affects the valuation according to the Cardmarket condition guide. A claim based on observable facts makes it much easier to get a useful response.
Before handling the card, photograph the sealed packaging if it shows scratches or moisture. Then record how it was protected and take photos of the front, back, four corners and edges. Take a front photo to locate the mark and an angled photo if a scratch is only visible under side light. Avoid filters or extreme contrast; they can exaggerate defects and reduce credibility. Keep the cover, rigid protection, and labels until the case is resolved. If the damage could have occurred during shipping, this material helps distinguish a discrepancy in the announced condition from a shipping incident.
Read the condition guide with the card in front of you
Cardmarket publishes grades as Mint, Near Mint, Excellent, Good, Light Played, Played and Poor, with descriptions and illustrative photographs. It does not assign the grade solely based on the age or value of the card: an old card does not automatically receive an additional margin of wear. Examine several defects together, since a small mark alone does not necessarily equate to a folded corner. Note why you believe the announced grade does not match and link the section of the guide you are applying. You can express reasonable uncertainty, for example: "The offer indicated NM; these marks on the back seem EX or lower according to the guide."
Do not confuse a price label or an external grade with the condition declared on the platform. A comment like "NM-" does not create an official category on its own; the Cardmarket guide explains that partial grades do not replace published levels. Manufacturing errors are also evaluated differently from wear, and it is advisable to describe them explicitly. The purpose of citing the guide is not to win a semantic debate, but to establish a shared reference so both parties can evaluate the same card and the same defect.
Write to the seller from the order
Cardmarket indicates that the first step when the condition is incorrect is to contact the seller. Use the conversation from the order, not an external channel, to keep the offer, photos and proposal together. A clear message can be: "I received the shipment today. The card advertised as NM has a pressure mark on the back corner and visible wear on the top edge. I have attached front, back and detail photos. Can we agree on a return or price adjustment?" Maintain a descriptive tone; you do not need to attribute intent to the seller to explain a real problem.
If there are multiple cards, list only the affected ones and their quantities. Distinguish the individual value of each to make any partial solution calculable. Propose a concrete solution, but listen to another that covers the problem. The official page considers agreements such as partial refunds and recommends talking first. When the defect is significant or the card is no longer useful for your collection, a return may be more logical than a small price adjustment. Do not alter or resell the card while negotiating, and keep the written conversation.
How to interpret the adjustment recommendation
Cardmarket's help suggests, as a starting point, a 10% refund of the product's value for each difference in condition level. It is a recommendation for negotiation, not an obligatory fee that resolves all cases. The same page warns that a Played or Poor card may not fit into this solution. For example, if the buyer needed a Near Mint copy for a collection, reducing the price a little may not meet the goal. If the seller and you agree on another amount or a return, write it in the order thread.
Always calculate based on the affected card, not the entire order, unless the agreement between both parties covers the lot. If there are language, edition, or finish differences in addition to condition, do not try to translate all problems into "a lower level." They are distinct discrepancies that can completely change the utility or value of the object. Provide photos and explain which solution you would accept. A reasonable negotiation starts from the original offer, the received card, and the options the platform provides for this order.
When to ask for help from Cardmarket
The page on problematic shipments recommends contacting support if you do not receive a response from the seller within five business days or if you do not reach an agreement. Open the consultation from the corresponding shipment page: this way the platform receives the data related to the order. Summarize the date of receipt, the affected card, the offered condition, the observed defect, the exchanged messages, and the requested solution. Attach the relevant photos and keep the packaging. If there is tracking or protection service, consult how to register the incident in that order before confirming a receipt without reservations.
Do not mark a problem as resolved if it still depends on a response. The confirmation and protection options may vary by shipping method and the status of the order. Follow the current instructions that Cardmarket shows in your case. Also, do not open multiple consultations for the same discrepancy without necessity: concentrate the information on the shipment page so support can reconstruct the sequence. If the seller proposes a solution, confirm in writing what is returned, what amount is refunded, and who assumes the return shipping before sending the card.
Professional and individual seller
Cardmarket distinguishes between purchases from professional sellers and those from individuals. Explain that with professional sellers, applicable withdrawal rights may exist, while with individuals, the solution usually depends more on the specific agreement about the incident. Do not assume that all purchases have identical timeframes or rights. Consult the seller's account type, the current platform conditions, and, if you intend to exercise a legal right, the official information applicable to your country and transaction. A poorly described card should be documented in both cases, but the resolution path may differ.
This distinction does not convert a grade disagreement into permission to ignore the order steps. In any case, contact from the platform, provide evidence, and request a clear solution. If you receive a response that does not address the defect, reformulate with a specific photo and the reference to the condition guide. If no agreement is reached, use support through the indicated path. Avoid threats or general legal statements that you have not verified; they often delay a solution that may be as simple as recognizing the error and adjusting the order.
Complete case example
Imagine you bought a card advertised as Excellent and received a copy with visible folding. Your case may include: a screenshot of the offer, a photo of the envelope, a front photo of the card, a detail of the fold, the back, a message to the seller from the order and the received response. In the message, indicate why the defect exceeds the announced grade according to the guide and propose a return or an agreement that you would actually accept. If five business days pass without a response or the negotiation fails, send the same set of evidence to support from the shipment page. This way, no one needs to guess which card you are talking about.
When closing the case, verify that the agreed adjustment or return appears where it should be and record the actual condition in your inventory if you keep the card. This last step avoids announcing it later with the incorrect grade. Prevention also starts when buying: for expensive cards, request real photos before paying and check that language, edition, finish, and condition are clearly listed in the offer. Good documentation can prevent conflict and, if it occurs, allow resolution with fewer messages.
Frequently asked questions
Must I confirm arrival before raising an issue?
Check the order’s issue option first. Cardmarket says protected-shipment problems should be reported before confirming receipt as correct.
Will a blurry photo be enough?
It rarely helps. Show the whole card, a clear close-up of the problem and the back.