How to grade TCG card condition: Mint, Near Mint, Excellent, LP, Played and Poor

Two people can look at the same card and describe it differently. Before a trade, do not just say “it is in good shape”: inspect edges, surface, corners, centering and any alteration.

Mint, Near Mint, Excellent, Lightly Played, Played and Poor provide a shared vocabulary, but they do not replace photos. The Cardmarket condition guide is a useful reference for understanding the scale and its limits.

The practical rule: describe the defect, not only the label

Start with the highest category another person could reasonably accept, then look for flaws that lower it. A Near Mint card should not hide whitening, scratches, creases or visible marks. If you are between two categories, disclose the lower one and show photos.

What each condition means

Mint: an almost flawless appearance. It is a demanding description, not a synonym for well kept.
Near Mint: very good condition, with minimal handling signs and no meaningful visible damage.
Excellent: small signs of use, especially on edges or corners, without major structural damage.
Lightly Played / LP: visible handling or storage wear while the card keeps its structure.
Played: clear use, scratches, worn edges or damage that noticeably affects appearance.
Poor: creases, water damage, alterations, inked edges or other severe damage.

In European marketplaces you may also see abbreviations such as NM, EX, GD, LP, PL and PO. Confirm which scale the other person is using.

Inspect five areas

Front: look for scratches, loss of shine, pressure marks and damage to the artwork.
Back: check stains, lines, creases and colour differences.
Edges: use side lighting to spot whitening without confusing it with a factory cut.
Corners: check dents, rounding and lifted layers.
Flatness: disclose persistent curling or water damage.

Foils, signed and altered cards

Foil cards reflect light and reveal small scratches. A signature, stamp, drawing or inked border also changes how the card should be described: do not present it as unaltered.

Agree before meeting

Send clear front and back photos, name the most important flaw and put the agreed condition in writing. In person, inspect the card before handing yours over. Transparency keeps a fair trade from becoming an argument.

Describe two defects without inventing a conversion

“Two white spots on the upper back corner and a surface scratch visible under angled light” is more informative than “NM/LP.” Photograph both and use the agreed scale. Cardmarket includes Good between Excellent and Light Played; do not automatically translate its categories into an American scale.

A marketplace condition category and a PSA grade are separate systems. Near Mint does not automatically mean PSA 8 or 9. Nor is there a universal percentage discount per category: compare the same version and document its defects.